ORIGIN2 min read

Jerome Bettis Lost A Thanksgiving Coin Toss. The NFL Changed The Rule.

A disputed overtime call in Detroit on Thanksgiving 1998 is why NFL captains now call the toss before the coin goes up.

On November 26, 1998, the Pittsburgh Steelers and Detroit Lions finished regulation tied at the Pontiac Silverdome. At the overtime coin toss, Steelers captain Jerome Bettis made the call while the coin was in the air. Bettis said he called tails. Referee Phil Luckett ruled that he had called heads.

Why heads counted

Football Zebras reports that Luckett heard Bettis say heads-tails and used the first word, as the rules required. NFL.com says enhanced audio later showed heads could be heard before tails. The coin landed tails, so Detroit won the toss.

How it ended

Detroit took the ball, and Jason Hanson kicked a 42-yard field goal to win 19-16, according to NFL.com. The Steelers never touched the ball in overtime.

The rule now

Football Zebras reports that starting the next week, referees had the captain call the toss before the flip. Rule 4, Section 2, Article 2 of the 2026 NFL rulebook says the call of heads or tails must be made by the visiting captain prior to the Referee's toss.

Quick answers

What happened with the Jerome Bettis coin toss?
Bettis said he called tails in overtime on Thanksgiving 1998. Referee Phil Luckett ruled he called heads first, and the coin landed tails, so Detroit won the toss.
Who won the 1998 Steelers-Lions Thanksgiving game?
The Lions, 19-16 in overtime, on a 42-yard Jason Hanson field goal.
When does an NFL captain call the coin toss?
Before the referee tosses the coin, under Rule 4, Section 2, Article 2.

Sources

If you think anything on this page is wrong, we want to know.

One football fact a day.

Sourced, short, and nothing to do with predictions.

Keep going

← All zip.football explainers